Back in the 1980 presidential campaign, Ronald Reagan used this phrase to great effect to fend off criticism that was untrue or exaggerated. Today, it’s a phrase we think about saying often, particularly when it comes to news reports about the OCC’s Quarterly Report on Bank Trading and Derivatives Activities.
The 2011 second quarter edition is just out and, as usual, it’s creating some misperceptions that need to be clarified. The New York Times, for example, reported on it and said that “The nation’s four biggest banks… are the biggest players, holding roughly 95 percent of the industry’s total exposure to derivatives.”
As we’ve noted in the past, the OCC report only covers part of the US market. The data includes derivatives exposures of US dealers and US subsidiaries of non-US dealers. But it does not include exposures arising from transactions between a US firm and a non-US dealer.
Even more importantly, the OTC derivatives market is global, with competitors from all geographic sectors. On a global basis, the five largest US-based dealers held 37 percent of total derivatives notional according to an analysis ISDA did last year. The G14 group of dealers (the 14 largest) held 82 percent of total notionals outstanding.
The depth and breadth of competition in OTC derivatives is also supported by data from SwapClear, which requires members to have at least $1 trillion in notional outstanding. There are at last count 38 separate dealer/members who meet this criterion.
This leads us to ask: which other global markets have as many firms competing for business as this one?
Latest
ISDA Trading Forum Tokyo: CEO Remarks
ISDA Derivatives Trading Forum Tokyo October 17, 2025 Opening Remarks Scott O’Malia ISDA Chief Executive Officer Good afternoon, and welcome to the ISDA Derivatives Trading Forum. It’s great to be back in Tokyo, and I’d like to begin by...
Future of Asset Management in Japan: CEO Remarks
Future of Asset Management in Japan October 17, 2025 Welcoming Remarks Scott O’Malia ISDA Chief Executive Officer Good morning, and welcome to this ISDA event on the Future of Asset Management in Japan. We’re delighted to be holding this...
New Report on Japan's Asset Management Ambitions
ISDA and Crisil Coalition Greenwich shows that derivatives are expected to play a pivotal role in Japan’s ambition to become a global leader in asset management, but some barriers need to be reduced to enable the country’s asset managers to...
The Derivatives Market in Japan
A healthy derivatives market is an important element to Japan’s plan to become a global leader in asset management. Asset managers are eager to increase their use of derivatives to better take and manage risk, but note that there is...