It’s Easter Monday. Europe is closed. The US wishes it were. Along comes this scary headline…which is even scarier because it’s from a column in TIME written by a contributor: Why Derivatives May Be the Biggest Risk for the Global Economy.
We furiously click through the link to get to the entire article. We read through it, drawing nary a breath. We see claims (with absolutely no attribution or substantiation) that the OTC derivatives market is bigger than the BIS says it is. Which means the risks are even greater than many had supposed.
We are puzzled.
And then we come to the piece de resistance, the giveaway:
“…in theory, at least, the total losses could add up to more money than there is in the entire world.”
A moment of clarity descends upon us. We “get” it.
It’s April 1. The column is an April Fool’s Day prank.
It has to be…because the story simply makes no sense. The venerable TIME would never run a column that confuses its facts so badly. It mixes up notional amounts outstanding with the level of OTC derivatives risk outstanding (which is properly measured by market value). If you do a $100 million interest rate swap, you agree to exchange payments based on the $100 million notional amount. You don’t actually exchange the $100 million.
We know people sometimes find OTC derivatives confusing, but we had imagined that by now just about everyone gets this point (or at least everyone with the yank to write a column in TIME). Notional does not measure risk. In fact, the amount at risk in OTC derivatives typically averages about 4% of the notional outstanding. And it’s less after you factor in collateralization and netting (about 0.2% of notional).
Unfortunately, the misguided notions on notional are not all that’s wrong with the column. It also fails to recognize the significant growth in central clearing, the progress made in increasing regulatory transparency, the continuing efforts in collateral management – all of which help to reduce risk.
We’re glad April Fool’s Day only comes once a year.
Latest
ISDA AGM Studio: Scott O'Malia and Chris Edmonds
Christopher Edmonds, president, fixed income & data services, at Intercontinental Exchange, speaks with Scott O’Malia, ISDA CEO, about how market volatility, regulatory change and technological transformation are reshaping global markets. The discussion explores what recent volatility has meant for participation,...
ISDA AGM Studio: Bill Borden, Microsoft
Bill Borden, corporate vice president, worldwide financial services, at Microsoft, speaks with Mark New, ISDA’s co-head of digital transformation and senior counsel, about how artificial intelligence (AI) is shaping the future of financial markets and the key factors firms should...
ISDA AGM Studio: Heath Tarbert
Heath Tarbert, president of Circle, speaks with ISDA CEO Scott O’Malia about the primary applications of stablecoins in derivatives markets and how key legal considerations – including bankruptcy treatment and settlement finality – are being addressed as digital assets become...
ISDA AGM Studio: Yuval Rooz
Yuval Rooz, co-founder and CEO of Digital Asset, speaks with ISDA CEO Scott O’Malia about the growing momentum behind tokenization, the most compelling use cases for derivatives markets and the remaining hurdles that need to be addressed to enable widespread...
