Partial Tear-Up and Other Position Allocation Tools

On May 28, ISDA and the Futures Industry Association (FIA) published a paper regarding partial-tear up (PTU). The paper includes a comparison between PTU and other rebalancing tools and how PTU could evolve.

Under business-as-usual conditions, the central counterparty (CCP) is the seller to every buyer and buyer to every seller and therefore has a matched book. For every position/contract with a member, there is an equal and opposite position/contract with another member. This means the CCP has no market risk. If a member of a CCP defaults, this member cannot service its positions anymore and the CCP no longer has a matched book and consequently now is exposed to market risk. With every market move, the CCP will have to pay or receive variation margin on behalf of the defaulter.

The CCP will, as part of its default management process, try to sell the defaulter’s positions/contracts. This can be done either via a central limit order book, by using a broker, by a direct sale, by running an auction, or by a combination of these approaches. Under all these options, the positions/contracts in the defaulter’s portfolio will be sold and a market price established.

It is possible that the CCP may find it difficult to re-establish a matched book. In this very extreme situation, there are a number of possible tools for derivatives the CCP can use to restore a matched book: partial tear-up and forced allocation, invoicing back and possibly cash settlement.

This paper describes the tools to restore a matched book and reviews these tools against some key principles and criteria:

  • Equitable risk distribution
  • Impact on financial stability
  • Risk reduction
  • Incentives for participants

ISDA and FIA conclude that PTU is the fairest tool with the best incentive structure. However, the associations believe that, depending on the asset class, PTU could be adapted and improved and propose potential improvements.

The considerations in this paper need to be evaluated based on the nuances of specific products, such as physically-settled repos, cash equities, foreign exchange and swaps, subject to compression, as well as market depth, market liquidity, open interest and maturity of products, etc.

Documents (1) for Partial Tear-Up and Other Position Allocation Tools

Paper on Enhancing Liquidity and Risk Management

As ISDA marks its 40th anniversary this year, it is an opportune time to reflect on the challenges and opportunities faced by the global derivatives markets over the past four decades. Rapid growth, continued innovation, regulatory reform, central clearing, margining,...

Trade Bodies Seek Delay on Third-Country CCP Rules

On October 21, ISDA and nine other trade associations – the Alternative Investment Management Association, the European Association of Co-operative Banks, the European Association of Corporate Treasurers, the European Banking Federation, the European Fund and Asset Management Association, the European...

ISDA and Tokenovate Launch CDM Taskforce

ISDA and Tokenovate have today announced the establishment of a new taskforce within the Fintech Open Source Foundation (FINOS) to accelerate operationalization of the Common Domain Model (CDM). The initiative responds to growing market demand for standardized, interoperable post-trade processing...

ISDA Trading Forum Sydney: CEO Remarks

ISDA Derivatives Trading Forum Sydney October 21, 2025 Opening Remarks Scott O’Malia ISDA Chief Executive Officer   Good morning, and welcome to the Derivatives Trading Forum. It’s great to be back in Sydney following our last trip back in August....